| Rank | Student | School | Years | | G | Total |
| 1 | Fred Johnson | Wellsville-Middletown | 1983-1986 | | 120 | 3552 |
| 2 | Bill Roundtree | Wellsville | 1979-1980 | | 118 | 3243 |
| 3 | Brad Parrack | Macks Creek | 1991-1994 | | 118 | 3156 |
| 4 | Tony Osburn | Mound City | 2018-2021 | | 116 | 3080 |
| 5 | Bill Bradley | Crystal City | 1958-1961 | | 112 | 3068 |
| 6 | Brad Hocker | Archie | 1989-1992 | | 104 | 3038 |
| 7 | Jay Lee | Glasgow | 2005-2009 | | 119 | 2999 |
| 8 | Barry Laurie | Versailles | 1975-1978 | | 105 | 2980 |
| 9 | Daniel Cutbirth | Hurley | 1995-1998 | | 108 | 2958 |
| 10 | Logan Thomazin | Walnut Grove | 2014-2017 | | 127 | 2891 |
| 11 | Ryder Joseph Williams | Versailles | 2020-2023 | | 108 | 2877 |
| 12 | Cody Campbell | Montrose | 1995-1998 | | 104 | 2816 |
| 13 | Marcus Walker | O'Hara | 2002-2005 | | 111 | 2789 |
| 14 | Josh Hume | Seymour | 1995-1998 | | 108 | 2786 |
| 15 | Stump, Arlo | Golden City | 2016-2020 | | 112 | 2734 |
| 16 | Aminu Mohammed | Greenwood | 2018-2020 | | 87 | 2709 |
| 17 | Drenin Dinkins | South Iron | 2018-2021 | | 118 | 2646 |
| 18 | Dale Stanley | Licking | 1964-1967 | | 118 | 2494 |
| 19 | Lane Duncan | Licking | 2011-2014 | | 112 | 2441 |
| 20 | Andrew Dalton | Ava | 2018-2021 | | 111 | 2431 |
| 21 | Benjamin M Denbow | Licking | 2008-2012 | | 114 | 2392 |
| 21 | Benjamin M Denbow | Licking | 2008-2012 | | 114 | 2392 |
| 23 | Carter Trumbore | Butler | 2020-2023 | | 107 | 2382 |
| 24 | Rafe Kalberloh | Lakeland | 2017-2021 | | 113 | 2237 |
| 25 | Sam Richardson Jr. | Hancock | 2016-2019 | | 104 | 2176 |
| 26 | Drew Apsher | Smithton | 2013-2016 | | 104 | 2130 |
| 27 | Nathan Burnett | Risco | 2015-2018 | | 107 | 2109 |
| 28 | Caleb Coen Brown | Sacred Heart | 2018-2021 | | 109 | 2105 |
| 29 | Lane Dunlap | Golden City | 2017-2020 | | 113 | 2068 |
| 29 | Brock Wakefield | South Iron | 2017-2020 | | 106 | 2068 |
| 31 | Chase Parrish | Montgomery County | 2013-2016 | | 109 | 2054 |
| 32 | Jacob Richard Elmore-Stellwagen | Montgomery County | 2020-2023 | | 111 | 2046 |
| 33 | Luke Northweather | Blair Oaks | 2018-2021 | | 102 | 2018 |
| 34 | Trenton Lyles | Sacred Heart | 2014-2017 | | 118 | 2007 |
| 35 | Andrew Almany | Licking | 2000-2003 | | 106 | 1885 |
| 36 | Trent Smith | Carl Junction | 2015-2018 | | 97 | 1829 |