| Rank | School | Year | | G | Total |
| 1 | Pattonsburg | 2019 | | 12 | 922 |
| 2 | Lamar | 2013 | | 15 | 883 |
| 3 | Southwest (Livingston County) | 2020 | | 13 | 826 |
| 4 | Odessa | 2019 | | 15 | 818 |
| 5 | Jackson | 2020 | | 14 | 781 |
| 6 | Concordia | 2011 | | 14 | 764 |
| 7 | Southwest (Livingston County) | 2019 | | 13 | 760 |
| 8 | Penney | 2010 | | 15 | 747 |
| 9 | Cameron | 2005 | | 14 | 741 |
| 10 | Kearney | 2003 | | 14 | 734 |
| 11 | Pattonsburg | 2018 | | 12 | 728 |
| 12 | Concordia | 2010 | | 14 | 727 |
| 13 | Mid-Buchanan | 2020 | | 14 | 726 |
| 14 | Maryville | 2016 | | 15 | 716 |
| 15 | Maryville | 2012 | | 16 | 715 |
| 16 | Christian Brothers College | 2014 | | 14 | 695 |
| 17 | Centralia | 2003 | | 14 | 675 |
| 18 | Joplin | 2019 | | 14 | 662 |
| 18 | Joplin | 2019 | | 14 | 662 |
| 20 | Valle Catholic | 2009 | | 15 | 661 |
| 21 | Monroe City | 2017 | | 15 | 624 |
| 22 | Wellington-Napoleon | 2006 | | 10 | 564 |
| 22 | Jackson | 2017 | | 11 | 564 |
| 24 | Boonville | 1961 | | 11 | 548 |
| 25 | Valle Catholic | 1966 | | 10 | 535 |
| 26 | Sweet Springs | 2019 | | 12 | 502 |
| 27 | John Burroughs | 1961 | | 8 | 400 |