| Rank | School | Year | | R | G | Total |
| 1 | La Plata | 2010 | | 276 | 20 | 13.800 |
| 2 | Mansfield | 1990 | | 260 | 20 | 13.000 |
| 3 | La Plata | 2009 | | 201 | 16 | 12.563 |
| 4 | Lakeland | 1998 | | 271 | 22 | 12.318 |
| 5 | Bishop LeBlond | 2000 | | 275 | 23 | 11.957 |
| 6 | Licking | 2013 | | 245 | 21 | 11.667 |
| 7 | Steelville | 1997 | | 232 | 20 | 11.600 |
| 8 | Mansfield | 1999 | | 285 | 25 | 11.400 |
| 9 | Hermitage | 2008 | | 284 | 25 | 11.360 |
| 10 | Summit Christian Academy | 2012 | | 327 | 29 | 11.276 |
| 11 | Westminster Christian Academy | 2017 | | 359 | 32 | 11.219 |
| 12 | Valley Park | 2017 | | 332 | 31 | 10.710 |