| Rank | School | Year | | G | Total |
| 1 | Hickman | 2017 | | 38 | 193 |
| 2 | Thayer | 2005 | | 27 | 178 |
| 3 | Summit Christian Academy | 2012 | | 29 | 176 |
| 4 | Christian Brothers College | 1991 | | 28 | 164 |
| 5 | Nixa | 2001 | | 31 | 158 |
| 6 | Lakeland | 1998 | | 22 | 154 |
| 7 | Plato | 2007 | | 23 | 153 |
| 8 | Walnut Grove | 2008 | | 21 | 151 |
| 9 | Central (Cape Girardeau) | 2000 | | 29 | 146 |
| 10 | Helias Catholic | 1988 | | 26 | 145 |
| 11 | Parkway North | 2012 | | 34 | 144 |
| 12 | Vianney | 2011 | | 35 | 142 |
| 12 | Francis Howell | 2011 | | 35 | 142 |
| 14 | Aurora | 2017 | | 32 | 141 |
| 15 | Monett | 2013 | | 26 | 136 |
| 16 | Exeter | 2017 | | 23 | 100 |