| Rank | School | Year | | TB | G | Total |
| 1 | Mansfield | 1999 | | 534 | 25 | 21.360 |
| 2 | Mansfield | 2000 | | 614 | 30 | 20.467 |
| 3 | Southern Boone | 2003 | | 455 | 23 | 19.783 |
| 4 | Bishop LeBlond | 2000 | | 449 | 23 | 19.522 |
| 5 | Westminster Christian Academy | 2007 | | 568 | 30 | 18.933 |
| 6 | Hickman | 1999 | | 439 | 24 | 18.292 |
| 7 | Northwest (Hughesville) | 2000 | | 412 | 23 | 17.913 |
| 8 | Herculaneum | 2001 | | 517 | 29 | 17.828 |
| 9 | Herculaneum | 1999 | | 474 | 27 | 17.556 |
| 10 | Francis Howell | 2021 | | 577 | 42 | 13.738 |